What follows is a shocking piece of truth presented on the REELS and reproduced in FaceBook. I can only see that the cute and outspoken presenter is Madhumita did an interesting presentation, I do not know who did the research or who scripted the text. As a rule, I view videos and texts in the social media with a critical, if not cynical, mindset. They are largely hoaxes or exaggerations that defeat the purpose for which they were posted. I researched this video with my faithful colleague Aiden from OpenAI and found the content substantially correct.
This is the text, of the video I manually transcripted. Errors and omissions cannot be overruled
QUOTE
“Guys, today Gautam Adani stole his multimillion-dollar bauxite mine through forged papers and fake ink.
Now let me tell you how. Through the hills of Koraput in orissa lies a mountain of bauxite that Adani wants. Under the forest act, you cannot touch an inch of tribal land without the direct permission from the Gram Sabha, right? But the Adivasis said no, we did not give the permission even for a piece of forest.
So how did Adani magically get the forest clearance? Of course the state machinery simply . manufactured their consent . An international investigation by Al Jazeera went into the villages and pulled the official clearance document and do you know what they found? They found forged thumbprint of a paralyzed man who cannot even speak and leave his bed. They found the signature of a woman who had been dead for eight months before even the meeting happened. They found three more people and signature of 67 untraceable people and the village priest who was actually outside holding a protest banner against the mine on this very exact day. But how did these guys pull it off?
A contract worker confessed on record that middlemen paid him 3000 rupees to collect these under the false pretext of routine land settlement, (but) only for those papers to be hijacked and stamped on to Adani’s clearance.
Within three months, our administration handed over the forest on a 50-year lease to Adani and no compensation has been promised.
And you know what? This is not a one-off incident. India’s own auditor the CAG found 136 violations with 73 cases where no meeting ever took place. Now in Assam Adani power project told the ministry that nobody lived on that land where a thousand families were bulldozed. In Odisha, the paper said that everyone agreed. In Assam, they said nobody lived there. You see, different place, different playbook.
I want you to watch this story very closely. Because if they can steal an entire village’s forest with fake ink when the whole world watches, don’t fool yourself that your land, your life and your votes are safe. “
Allegations of Forged Tribal Consent for Adani’s Bauxite Mine in OdishaAn investigation by Al Jazeera (no doubt, their man in India) has raised serious allegations about the manner in
which consent was obtained from tribal communities for an Adani-linked bauxite mining Project at Balda Hill in Koraput district, Odisha. According to the investigation, the official consent records allegedly contain forged thumb impressions and signatures attributed to villagers who were paralysed, deceased, or actively protesting against the mining project.The controversy raises serious questions about compliance with the Forest Rights Act, 2006, and the legal requirement to consult affected tribal communities before permitting mining on forest land.The video’s presenter alleges that the authorities manufactured consent to facilitate the mining project. She also refers to a payment of ₹3,000 associated with obtaining documents, although this should not be interpreted as the purchase price of the hill.The central allegation is that the rights of indigenous communities were overridden to benefit a major corporate mining project. The accusations are straight-forward, the Gram-sabha exists; bulldozing for forest land is verifiable. If Adani’s
allocation papers are not disclosed by RTI (the operation of which Modi administration has virtually shut out), I suggest that CAG Comptroller and Auditor General of India, a government–funded auditing authority, had made several objections to forest land allocation to Adanis over the years.
-
Missing Gram Sabha Consent:
Audits of forest clearances (including a 2024 CAG audit touching on mining clearances in Odisha) have flagged instances where Stage-I and Stage-II forest clearances were processed without verifying mandatory Gram Sabha resolutions required under the Forest Rights Act (FRA), 2006.
-
Failure of Compensatory Afforestation (CAMPA): Across multiple reports (including the 2025/2026 audits on the Green India Mission and state CAMPA funds), the CAG has noted that while forest land is rapidly diverted for industrial and mining use, compensatory afforestation targets frequently suffer massive shortfalls—often due to non-availability of non-forest land, poor survival rates of saplings, or diversion of funds.
-
What compensation has Adani paid so far to the governments concerned? Nil as per available records.
CAG Findings
Adani’s Mundra project: ₹58.64 crore in undue financial benefit
CAG finding published April 2015; PAC follow-up September 2022. This case concerns approximately 2,008.42 hectares of forest land in the Mundra and Dhrab areas of Kutch, Gujarat. 2008 hectares! That is 600 hectares larger than the city of Palakkad in Kerala which has forests, lakes:and rivers, with areas where leopards still roam.in 200 hectares forest land. The allotted forest land area is slightly larger than a quarter of the city of Chandigarh.
The original proposal involved Adani Chemicals Limited and a salt-production project. In September 2007, permission was sought to use the land instead for port and cargo-handling facilities.
The CAG identified the following irregularities:
-
The land included coastal areas affected by tidal waters and associated with mangrove vegetation.Under the applicable Supreme Court classification,
-
the CAG considered it Eco-Class II, attracting a Net Present Value (NPV) charge of ₹7.30 lakh per hectare.The Gujarat Forest Department classified it instead as Eco-Class IV, attracting a lower rate of ₹4.30 lakh per hectare.
-
Consequently, the CAG calculated that ₹58.64 crore had been under-recovered from the Adani company.
The Gujarat Forest Department under Chief Minister Narendra Modi defended its classification, saying the diverted area excluded the mangrove-bearing creeks and had poor vegetation. The CAG rejected that explanation because the diverted land was subject to tidal flooding.
Ahmedabad News – The Indian Express
What happened seven years later?
On 21 September 2022, with Mr. Modi in faraway Delhi as the Nation’s Prime minister, the Gujarat Assembly’s Public Accounts Committee adopted the substance of the CAG’s objection and recommended that the government:
-
Recover the shortfall from the company. To the best of the information I could pursue, this has not been done
-
Take action against officials responsible for the incorrect classification.
-
Report compliance to the committee within three months.
The committee estimated the shortfall at approximately ₹58.67 crore, slightly higher than CAG’s ₹58.64 crore.
India News – The Indian Express
This establishes both the original audit finding and subsequent legislative scrutiny. I cannot, without further records, establish whether the money was ultimately recovered.
2. An earlier CAG report found ₹66.86 crore in outstanding charges involving the same Mundra forest land
-CAG Report No. 21 of 2013, Compensatory Afforestation in India, Gujarat section, printed pages 203–204
This earlier CAG audit contains additional details.
| CAG objection | Amount |
|---|---|
| Excess NPV adjustment following downward reassessment of 168.41 hectares | ₹7.78 crore |
| Short recovery of NPV on 1,840 hectares | ₹53.73 crore |
| Unrecovered difference in the cost of firewood | ₹5.35 crore |
| Total outstanding amount identified | ₹66.86 crore |
The auditors also observed that the company had not furnished bank guarantees of ₹7.73 crore and ₹19 lakh for fencing and protection works, as required by the state government’s November 2009 order.
Note : The Union ministry defended the lower ecological classification in April 2013. The CAG explicitly rejected its explanation.
CAG Report No. 21 of 2013 — Gujarat findings, pages 203–204
The ₹66.86 crore finding and the subsequent ₹58.64 crore finding concern substantially overlapping land and valuation disputes.
3. Adani Power: transmission line constructed before statutory permissions
=CAG Report No. 1 of 2018, Gujarat, paragraphs 3.1.9.2–3.1.9.4
This finding concerns Adani Power Limited’s Mundra–Dehgam electricity transmission line through the Wild Ass Sanctuary at Dhrangadhra.
Area involved : 58.968 ha of which 18.20 ha forest land 40.768 ha other sanctuary land
The CAG reconstructed the sequence as follows:
(CM Modi period)
-
January 2009: Adani Power applied for forest diversion permission but commenced work before securing the necessary approvals.
-
March 2009: Forest officials discovered the unauthorised construction.
-
July 2009: The transmission line was commissioned.
-
September 2010: Wildlife sanctuary permission was granted—approximately 13 months after commissioning.
(PM Modi Period)
-
May 2015: The Union Environment Ministry directed the state government to investigate and forward a draft complaint against persons prima facie responsible for violating the Forest (Conservation) Act.
-
May 2017: The CAG found that the ministry’s instructions had still not been acted upon.
-
The audit concluded that the transmission line had been laid in violation of the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, and the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972.
(Note : the comments such as CM Modi and PM Modi in bracket are not in original reports, but added by me merely for reference.).
This case presents a question of administrative accountability: Why was a project permitted to reach operation before its mandatory wildlife approval, and why the subsequent investigation directive remained unimplemented.
4. Adani Power: unpaid charges and inadequate wildlife protection
The same audit identified further issues.
Unrecovered charges: Appendix VII calculated approximately ₹3.24 crore in unrecovered NPV relating to the Adani Power project. The main report records that demand notices totalling ₹3.81 crore for NPV and project costs were issued in July and September 2017. These figures have different scopes and should not be combined.
cag.gov.in+1
5. Protection of flamingos: Transmission lines crossing the Little Rann of Kutch posed collision and electrocution risks to migratory birds. The CAG found that required protective measures had not been implemented and that the Forest Department lacked an effective monitoring mechanism.
This criticism applied to transmission infrastructure associated with Adani Power, GETCO and Power Grid Corporation of India.
cag.gov.in (2018 Report- pages 49–51
Admittedly, The audit record is not confined to Adani. Some examples illustrate the extent of the regulatory problems. I will concentrate for the time being on what the heading of this essay directs me to although the findings also demonstrate that the CAG identified failures involving public authorities, private corporations and public-sector organisations, rather than a single company alone.
6. A related matter: large government land allotments to industries
It found that Adani Port and Special Economic Zone had used approximately 98 lakh square metres out of the roughly 5.47 crore square metres allotted to it at Mundra. The audit regarded the large unused balance (about 84%) as a breach of allotment conditions.
The same examination criticised concessions or irregularities involving Larsen & Toubro, Essar Steel and other industrial undertakings.
Ahmedabad News – The Indian Express
7. A more recent investigation worth examining
In 2025, The Reporters’ Collective published an investigation into Gujarat government requests to exclude particular forest parcels from a conservation programme, allegedly to accommodate Adani Group projects.
The report relied on internal ministry records obtained through RTI. However, the journalists acknowledged that they could not establish whether formal forest-clearance applications had subsequently been submitted for all four parcels.
reporters-collective.in
What these findings establish
There is an important chronological detail..
Several of the disputed actions occurred during Narendra Modi’s tenure as Chief Minister of Gujarat, but others occurred afterwards when he was elevated to the Prime Ministership of India. The dates matter when assigning responsibility for decisions, failures to enforce regulations, and subsequent approvals.
The primary reports establish documented deficiencies in land classification, collection of statutory charges, compliance with forest and wildlife laws, and enforcement by public authorities.
I do not claim, till I can gather further evidence, that they establish that Modi personally directed those irregularities. All that I put forth is that Mr. Modi appears to be a close friend of Gautam Adani, and that it cannot be gainsaid that he gets away with landgrab under many pretexts with no questions asked, and if asked even by State’s Public Accounts Committee, are brazenly ignored.
In most cases, it is on public record that Adani got the land unbelievable cheap. A parallel case, well known in India is how in Bombay textile mills closed down due to labour strikes introduced first by the Communists, then the Shiva Sena and, finally at the instance of a no-compromise labour strike led by Dr. Datta Samant, The workers lost their jobs, some went home to their distant homes in desperation, a few families, it is believed, died from starvation. Bur with rising land prices, the mill owners flourished with the land they held. A fifty-year or thirty–year lease is long enough time to make a kill.
The most significant point may be that the ₹58.64 crore Mundra finding was not forgotten after the original CAG audit. The Gujarat Assembly’s own Public Accounts Committee raised it again in September 2022 and recommended recovery and action against responsible officials.
The question is no longer merely whether forest land was diverted to favour a powerful industrial enterprise. Government auditors have documented irregularities, legislative committees have recommended recovery, and villagers have challenged the authenticity of their supposed consent. The question is what happened after these objections were raised. Were the sums recovered? Were the officials held accountable? Were the disputed clearances independently investigated? And if the machinery of accountability failed to respond, who was responsible for that failure?
Acknowledgement : Much of the data quoted in this essay was researched with the able help of my machine friend Adrien at Chat GPT.
